In this article
- What is a raw diet for dogs?
- What the FDA found
- Nutritional balance
- Claimed benefits vs. evidence
- Who should avoid raw feeding
- If you choose raw: a safety plan
- How much does a raw diet cost?
- How to choose a commercial raw food
- Transitioning to or from raw
- Common mistakes
- Raw feeding vocabulary
- Raw food and people in the household
- A weekly raw-feeding routine (if you choose raw)
- Questions for your veterinarian
- Alternatives that keep some benefits
Raw feeding has passionate fans and serious critics. Before you decide, it helps to separate what is known — especially about bacteria and nutritional balance — from what is promised in marketing. This guide covers the types of raw diets, the safety data, how to reduce risk if you choose raw, and what it costs.
What is a raw diet for dogs?
A raw food diet for dogs is built on uncooked animal products. Common formats:
| Format | Description | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Commercial frozen raw | Ground meat, organs and bone, sold frozen | Look for “complete and balanced” |
| Freeze-dried raw | Raw food with water removed | Still treated as raw for safety |
| High-pressure processed (HPP) raw | Raw food treated with pressure to reduce bacteria | Reduces, does not eliminate, risk |
| Homemade raw (often called BARF or prey model) | Owner-assembled meat, bone, organ, sometimes vegetables | Needs professional formulation |
| Raw toppers | Small amounts added to kibble | Same handling risks |
What the FDA found
In a two-year study, the FDA Center for Veterinary Medicine screened more than 1,000 pet food samples. Raw food was tested in the second year:
| Type of pet food | Samples tested | Positive for Salmonella | Positive for Listeria monocytogenes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Raw pet food | 196 | 15 | 32 |
| Jerky-type treats | 190 | 0 | 0 |
| Semi-moist dog food | 120 | 0 | 0 |
| Dry dog food | 120 | 0 | 0 |
| Dry cat food | 120 | 1 | 0 |
The FDA concluded that raw pet food was more likely to be contaminated with disease-causing bacteria than the other types tested. These bacteria can make people sick through handling food, bowls or the dog itself.
Nutritional balance
The FDA explains that “complete and balanced” foods must meet AAFCO nutrient profiles or pass a feeding trial. Many commercial raw foods carry this statement; many homemade raw diets do not meet it. The AAFCO guide to reading labels explains where to find the nutritional adequacy statement. Products labeled “for supplemental or intermittent feeding” are not meant to be the whole diet.
Claimed benefits vs. evidence
| Claim | What we know |
|---|---|
| Shinier coat | Often reported; fat content and novelty can explain it; any complete diet can produce a good coat |
| Cleaner teeth | Not a substitute for tooth brushing and veterinary dental care |
| Better digestion, smaller stools | Raw foods are often highly digestible; so are many cooked foods |
| Stronger immune system | No strong evidence |
| “Natural” for dogs | Dogs have lived alongside people and eaten cooked scraps for thousands of years |
Who should avoid raw feeding
- Homes with babies, young children, older adults, pregnant people or immunocompromised members
- Therapy dogs that visit hospitals or nursing homes (check the program’s rules)
- Puppies, unless the diet is complete for growth and formulated by a professional
- Dogs with certain medical conditions, or on immunosuppressive drugs
If you choose raw: a safety plan
Follow the FDA’s food-safety approach: keep raw food frozen until use, thaw safely, keep it separate from human food, sanitize surfaces, wash hands after handling food, bowls or feces, and do not let your dog lick faces right after eating. Throw away uneaten food.
How much does a raw diet cost?
Cost depends on the format and your dog’s size. Commercial complete raw foods are usually among the most expensive options per day; homemade raw can be cheaper per pound but adds the cost of a nutritionist’s formulation, supplements and freezer space. Compare price per day for your dog’s calorie needs, not price per bag.
How to choose a commercial raw food
- “Complete and balanced” statement for your dog’s life stage
- Manufacturer’s food-safety process explained (for example HPP)
- Clear feeding guide and calories per serving
- Customer service that answers questions about formulation
- Recall history checked
Transitioning to or from raw
Change diets gradually over about a week, mixing increasing amounts of the new food, or follow your veterinarian’s transition plan. Watch stools, appetite and weight, and stop if your dog has vomiting or diarrhea.
Common mistakes
- Thawing raw food on the counter.
- Feeding “80/10/10” ratios without a formulated supplement plan.
- Washing raw meat in the sink and splashing bacteria.
- Letting children feed or handle a raw-fed dog’s bowl.
- Feeding cooked bones.
- Assuming freeze-dried means bacteria-free.
Raw feeding vocabulary
| Term | Meaning |
|---|---|
| BARF | Often expanded as “biologically appropriate raw food”; meat, bone, organ, plus fruit and vegetables |
| Prey model | Whole or ground meat, bone and organ, usually without plant ingredients |
| 80/10/10 | Common rule of thumb for muscle meat, bone and organ — not a formulation |
| Complete raw | Commercial product formulated to meet a nutrient profile |
| Topper or mixer | Small amount added to another food |
Rules of thumb like 80/10/10 describe ingredient proportions, not nutrient levels. Two “80/10/10” diets made with different meats can have very different vitamin and mineral content.
Raw food and people in the household
Bacteria in raw pet food can reach people through:
- hands, cutting boards, counters and sinks used to prepare food;
- the dog’s bowl and the area around it;
- the dog’s mouth and fur (licking faces and hands);
- the dog’s feces in yards and play areas.
This is why the FDA’s advice focuses on hygiene and why households with vulnerable people are often advised to avoid raw feeding altogether.
A weekly raw-feeding routine (if you choose raw)
| Day | Task |
|---|---|
| Weekly | Move a few days of portions from freezer to refrigerator in a sealed container on the bottom shelf |
| Each meal | Serve, wash hands, remove leftovers promptly |
| After each meal | Wash and sanitize the bowl and prep area |
| Daily | Pick up feces in the yard |
| Monthly | Weigh the dog and check body condition |
| Every visit | Tell your vet the dog eats raw food — it matters for diagnosing illness |
Questions for your veterinarian
- Is a raw diet appropriate for my dog’s age and health?
- Is anyone in my household at higher risk from foodborne bacteria?
- Is the product I chose complete and balanced for my dog?
- What signs of illness should prompt a call?
- Could a gently cooked fresh diet meet my goals with less risk?
Bringing the product label to your appointment makes this conversation much easier.
Alternatives that keep some benefits
If you like the idea of fresh, minimally processed food, gently cooked fresh diets formulated to be complete and balanced offer a middle ground without raw-meat bacteria. Compare the options in fresh vs. kibble vs. raw, or learn how to cook safely in homemade dog food recipes. The WSAVA nutrition guidelines are a good basis for that conversation with your veterinarian. More in the dog food guide.
Guide · $9The Dog and Cat Food Guide
Guide · $9The Dog and Cat Food Guide28-page PDF: read pet food labels, guaranteed analysis, dry matter, calories by weight, food switching and toxic foods, plus printable worksheets.Buy now →Frequently asked questions
Is raw dog food safe?
It carries a higher risk of harmful bacteria than cooked or dry foods. In an FDA study, raw pet food was the only category with many samples positive for Salmonella and Listeria. Dogs may carry these bacteria without looking sick and shed them in saliva and feces.
Is a raw diet better for dogs?
Claims of shinier coats, better teeth or stronger immunity are common, but the evidence comes mostly from owner reports. A complete and balanced cooked or dry diet meets nutritional needs without the bacterial risk.
Who should not feed raw dog food?
Households with young children, older adults, pregnant people or anyone with a weakened immune system face higher risk from Salmonella and Listeria. If your dog visits hospitals as a therapy dog, ask the program about its rules on raw diets.
Are freeze-dried raw foods safer?
Freeze-drying removes water but does not necessarily kill bacteria. Some products use an extra step such as high-pressure processing. Check the label and handle freeze-dried raw food with the same hygiene as fresh raw meat.
Can I make a balanced raw diet at home?
Only with a recipe formulated by a veterinary nutritionist. Homemade raw diets based on rough ratios of meat, bone and organ can be unbalanced in calcium, phosphorus, vitamins and trace minerals.
Are raw bones safe for dogs?
Bones can break teeth, cause choking and block or puncture the gut. Cooked bones are especially dangerous because they splinter. Discuss any bone feeding with your veterinarian first.
Sources
- Get the Facts! Raw Pet Food Diets can be Dangerous to You and Your Pet↗oficial
- "Complete and Balanced" Pet Food↗oficial
- Reading Labels — Understanding Pet Food↗
